David Bednar’s initial years in Pittsburgh have largely been seen as fortunate, as the local talent evolved into a two-time All-Star closer for a team with aspirations of ascending in the ranks. However, while the Pirates show promise, Bednar’s performance is currently faltering. The right-hander experienced his third blown save in four opportunities on Tuesday, allowing Detroit to stage a comeback and secure a 5-3 victory.
What struck most was not just the walks or the two batters he hit, which aided the Tigers’ resurgence, but the unexpected sound of boos directed at Bednar from the home crowd. Since his arrival from San Diego in a trade involving Joe Musgrove in January 2021, Bednar has been warmly embraced by Pittsburgh fans. Despite taking accountability for his display, Bednar’s teammates are more distressed by the treatment he received from the crowd upon exiting the game.
First baseman Rowdy Tellez emphasized the importance of solidarity, stating, “We don’t do that out here.” He deemed the crowd’s reaction unacceptable and stressed the need for improvement within the Pittsburgh community. Bednar expressed gratitude for Tellez’s support but acknowledged the challenge he currently faces.
Having grown up in Mars, a suburb approximately 30 minutes from PNC Park, the 29-year-old has been a mainstay in the bullpen over the past two seasons. Known for his powerful fastball and competitive demeanor, Bednar typically takes to the mound to the tune of “Renegade” by Styx, a rock anthem that serves as a rallying cry for the Pittsburgh Steelers’ defense during home games.
Despite the Pirates’ promising 9-3 start, Bednar has encountered difficulties. While previous struggles against Miami and Baltimore did not prove costly for his team, Tuesday’s game saw him struggle to maintain the lead. Failing to retire a significant number of batters, Bednar allowed the Tigers to level the score. Manager Derek Shelton attributes Bednar’s struggles to rust accumulated during his recovery from a lat injury.
With a day off before their upcoming road trip, the Pirates are considering various options, including temporarily shifting seven-time All-Star reliever Aroldis Chapman to the closer role. Shelton emphasized the need to identify and address Bednar’s command issues.
Despite the frustration, Bednar remains optimistic, viewing the current setback as a minor hurdle in a long season. He believes the team’s potential to contend in the NL Central will ultimately outweigh these early challenges.
